Retail Sector a FDI – Foreign Direct Investment Policy chungchang hi Parliament lamah an khel nasa em em a. Opposition mai nilo, UPA allies te ngei pawn he policy hi an dem zia an ti lang a ni. Vawiin Lok Sabha leh Rajya Sabha session pawh an inhnial nasat lutuk avangin naktuk a tan an adjourn phah bawk.
Engtin nge he policy hian retail sector leh kan economy a tih danglam ang? He FDI policy sawi dan chuan khua (city) 1 million population ai a tam awmna ah chuan multi brand retail outlets ah 51% FDI a phal mai bakah single brand outlet ah 100% FDI a phal dawn a ni. Hemi awmzia chu khawvel a retail outlets lian ber ho Walmart, Carrefour, Tesco leh company dang lian tak tak tamtak te hi India ramah awlsam deuhvin an rawn lut thei dawn a ni.
He cabinet decision hre duh tan he slideshare hi han en thuak ru:
Ka khaikhin theih dan ber chu Mizoram ah Vai sumdawng rawn luh kan phalloh ang vel hi a ni ber mai. A hmun a awm ho, khami ram neitute ngei kha, an business an rawn khawih chhe vek thei a ni (a tlawm zawk a an hralh vang te, thil tha zawk leh tam zawk an zawrh vang te, contact leh influence an neih that zawk vang te etc etc).
McKinsey Report sawi dan chuan India retail business hi $450 billion zat man a ni tawh a, hei hi Global retail giants te tan chuan business opportunity tha lutuk a ni. Mahse chutih rual chuan local business (a bikin micro leh SME – Small Medium Enterprise) ho chu an chhiat phah thei bawk a ni.
A awmzia ber chu loneitu (farmer) ten an thlai leh products ho direct in Walmart te hnenah an hralh thei dawn a ni, chu pawh a man to zawkin. Walmart ang te chuan chu man sang zawk chu an ngam mai bakah an (domestic) competition chhiatna tur a nih avangin an lo lei ang. Chuan middlemen/intermediary (farmer leh retail outlet inkar a lo awm agent hran hran) an awm tak loh avangin a man tlawm deuhvin mipui te hnenah an hralh chhawng leh thei dawn a ni. Hetah hi chuan producers (loneitu), retail outlets (walmart etc) leh consumers (keimahni) in he policy hi kan hlawkpui ngei ang. Mahse sawi tawh angin micro leh SME domestic industry leh family business ho chu an chhe vek thei a ni.
Farmers te tan a that theih rual rualin, thalo lamah pawh a kal thei tho a ni. Chuan distribution leh supply chain an monopolize theih avangin economy tan a thalovang tih thawm te pawh a awm tho. Sawi tawp chuan he thil hi chu a debate theih ve hle a, employment chungchangah pawh heng retail sector thar te hian employment opportunity thar rawn siam mahse, micro leh SME ho sector ah unemployment a siam ve tho tih lam te pawh a ni.
Hei vang hian Parliament ah chuan an inhnial nasa hle a, Karunanidhi (UPA ally) leh Jayalalitha (NDA ally) te pawn Tamilnadu ah hetiang foreign players ho rawn luh an oppose dawn thu an sawi a, chuan UPA ally dang Trinamool Congress te pawh an bengchheng hle a ni hemi policy dem hian. Chutih lai chuan BJP leader Uma Bharti chuan Walmart store an raw sak vaih chuan a hal nghal dawn a ti bawk. hahaha… 
He article hi in chhiar peih chuan lo chhiar ve ru. A ngaihnawm khawp mai. A ziaktupa rawn thlirna chu a dang daih.
moneylife.in: 100% FDI in retail in India, good or bad…
There is a lot to be said for big retail to come to India, but we cannot simply be taken in and mimic something which is being pushed down our throats because those who make the policy appear to not have the faintest clue on how retail really works in India.
If there were clear answers in black and white to the question, there would really be no need for any debate on the issue, but the truth is that it is simply not that simple. On a philosophical and emotional level, the answer could be that any form of foreign participation in a domestic market is rife with dangers of the colonialism sort, but in this day and age, while the core concept of being wary of foreign dominance may still be true, the fact remains that there are plenty of ways to ensure that it works on a win-win basis for all concerned.
The main problem with the current status of foreign direct investment (FDI) in retail in India is that it does not provide a level playing field to other players of the domestic and small sort. In addition, it appears to take a rather naive and simplistic view on certain aspects, which like myths being repeated, tend to become urban legends. On the other hand, no country can afford to take on an isolationist approach.
As this writer sees it, with a holistic view of the subject and not just based on jingoism of the “burn down the malls” (right view) and “bad for farmers” (left view) sort, but on rational evaluation of larger issues, there are some points which need to be straightened out. Large retail is inevitable, and that is a simple truth, but there has to be larger perspective for public good which seems to be missing from this policy. The people of India come first, including those who want a better product or service buying or selling experience, and at the end of the day it is their wallets which will decide where they go.
But at the same time, the government, with the policy as outlined above, cannot sell the baby with the bath-water, and make things worse. Some suggestions:
1) The present Agriculture Produce Market Committee (APMC) Act requires urgent revamp if we really want to help the rural and agricultural sectors with a better go to market scenario. This, along with rapid introduction of the goods and services tax (GST) as well as ease of inter- and intra-state movement of foodgrain, agri products and fresh produce, would do more to improve matters, as well as do wonders for our economy in a variety of ways—most of all in terms of controlling prices as well as reducing storage and transit losses.
2) The policy shown above makes a case that “brands” by big FDI retailers need to be carried across borders without in any way making it clear that the quality of those brands needs to be same across borders, too. As of now we see that with these manufacturers and retailers there is one lower quality for sale in India and there is a better quality for sale in developed countries—case in point being soft drinks, processed foods, confectionery, electronics, motor vehicles and others. If anything is by way of a different quality for India for price or other reasons, then let it be clearly marked as such.
3) Specifically in the case of packaged and processed foods, the policy does not say anything about adherence to best case scenarios in terms of labelling of ingredients and avoiding misleading marketing ploys, thereby leading to a situation where outright dangerous products are foisted on Indian consumers. The amount of product detail available for consumers in developed countries must be matched for India, too. India cannot become a vast chemistry lab for processed foods or anything else.
[Read complete article at source]
Chuan Bonus reading: Minister of Commerce Anand Sharma a public letter, nichin lawka an release. A rawn sawi tum chu he Policy an siam nachhan a ni ber mai e.
NDTV: Anand Sharma’s letter to political parties on FDI in retail
As you are aware, the Union Cabinet has taken a decision for liberalization of the Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) policy in Multi-Brand Retail, which holds the potential of transforming rural economy and unlocking the supply chain efficiencies in the agri-business.
The policy has evolved after a process of intense stakeholder consultation which commenced on 6 July 2010, when a discussion paper was floated by our Ministry. Comments from a wide cross section of stakeholders including farmers associations, industry bodies, consumer forums, academics, traders associations, international investors were analysed in depth before the matter was deliberated by the Committee of Secretaries on July 22, 2011.
Similar Posts:
- Reliance Retail opens shop
- India will be as rich as America in 2030
- St Thomas-A piece of his bone
- Hindi nge Burmese development atan tha zawk ang?
- Foreign language training for Mizo youths
November 28th, 2011 at 6:18 pm
#47 funny.. mizoram ah KFC, Mc Donals etc… kan la zo lo ang..awm ve ta pawh ni se Mizoram Economy leh population leh way of living ngaihtuah in kum 3 vel tal chu break even point a an kal a ngai ang..
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 6:29 pm
@Tete-i, KFC chu kum 2/3 vel liam ta khan siam an tum a. Mah se KFC in an risk ngamlo. An hlawk an ringlo a.
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 6:33 pm
Foreign MNC chain inlet siam lo hian home grown enterprises generate tum zawk teh ang u, an quality leh best prctices leh products te duoplicate in..
eg..KFC kher rawn luh angai ami, an mahni style in KFC (Kawlhawk Fried Chicken) te pawh siam ila,
P.S. kawlhawk partnership karega…an menu leh siam dan hi chu ka hre vek tawh ania..hihiihihi…servive girls pawh international ngat TAHAN lam product kan chah ang
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 6:35 pm
zualbonez chu ka zirtir uluk bawka a comment tha thei khermai.
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 6:37 pm
Wastern brands SAL (slave ) leh consumeristic society lutuk ah hi chuan inchhuah lo teh ang u..Home grown karega
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 6:47 pm
Hetiang lam hi chu Zuala hian a hre roh riau a, a comment ka lo nghakhlel khawp mai a. Mahse a Socialist leh lutuk a, a thu a lai lo tlatin ka hria. Tin, Sakawlh kawng insial mek hi dan theih ani tak tak dawn chuang lo bawk. Mahse, Lily-a nen hian kan expert neih an ni miau bawk si a.
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 6:49 pm
zualbonez a sawi ang khian, western hla aichuan heitang hle tehi ngaihsan zawk tur.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bLpROhIg9eA
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 6:57 pm
PAwn lam copy lutuk chuan hetiang ang deuh hian ka buai nuai mia tur ania
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EZGmKO9Rogc
afterthought:
One Steve dies and a million mourn, one million children die in africa and no one mourns…
Multi national corporations tam zawk hian an mahni profit bak an ngaihtuah lo..India khawvela malnourished naupang tamna ber hian unequal and exclusive development kan pan chho zel anih hi…
Dosclaimer: Selective FDi ka support ve tho
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 7:01 pm
zualbonez heihi mawi i ti em.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v.....re=related
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 7:05 pm
funny leh..ka mur ka mur ka za vek…hahahaa…hahthlak mai mai..huizzzz
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 7:08 pm
KFC (Kawlhawk Fried Chicken)
Zualbon i sual thai emai.. A sek teh mai ania ooo, a kick boxing voikhat poh dol zo lo tur chuan ching toh suh lol
KFC taktik i thiam a, helai local-a i practise chuan a hit chur2 viau mai thei, mahse an taktik hi an roh hmel sia, jail bang zur or tangka chawi a hlauhawm, in partnershp deal chu cancel leh zok mei ru.. Advaai tenau
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 7:13 pm
Hetiang hi mi in sawi a
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v.....re=related
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 7:16 pm
hahaha lrp, ava pui miah miah ve leee.
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 7:18 pm
Lo share churchur teh u..Mizo Beaver!
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 7:24 pm
Lily…Colonel Kawlhawk nen in partnerhsip chuan Burma sipai sawrkar thla zap hnuaiah hlauh nei miah loin kan awm thei ang..no problemo
Lrpa..hahahaha..I video chu wonderboy an comment teh se…lolzzz..tetlai atang riltam a ngah ve viau ani ang Dui- teen han KFC khel miah2 mai chu ..hahaha
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 7:30 pm
zualbonez says : KFC kher rawn luh angai ami, an mahni style in KFC (Kawlhawk Fried Chicken) te pawh siam ila,
P.S. kawlhawk partnership karega…an menu leh siam dan hi chu ka hre vek tawh ania..hihiihihi…servive girls pawh international ngat TAHAN lam product kan chah ang
Awke… Awke…
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 7:32 pm
zualbonez Says: Lily…Colonel Kawlhawk nen in partnerhsip chuan Burma sipai sawrkar thla zap hnuaiah hlauh
nei miah loin kan awm thei ang..no problemo
Hei pawh, Awke… Awke…
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 7:34 pm
A bengvarthlak hle mai.
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 7:50 pm
2000 bawr chho vel kha Corporate level a sumdawnna ah “Retail is future” tih kha an sawi chhen hlawm a, a hnu ah shopping mall an rawn awm teuh hlawm tak kha mawle.FDI retail hi rawn awm ngei se chu that ka ring khawp mai, mahse Mizoram angah chuan lo beisei vak chi pawh a ni lo. Vishal mega mart ho khan vawikhat an rawn thli thlai khan 7000sg ft vel hmun an mamawh, khawiah mah chutiang hmuh tur a awm lo Aizawl ah. Aizawl a Company ho rawn lut duh an problem ang chiah hi Shillonng ah pawh khuan a ni tho nia, Location ah an buai nasa ve khawp mai. Hmun zawl zau a ngai, chutiang chu Aizawl ah a awm mawlh lo. KFC, Mc donald tih vel pawh hi mipui mimir lei ngam chi a ni lo, burger Rs 400 man te hi mipui tam zawkin kan la afford lo, Mizo ho hi nalh deuh a inchei si hian pachhe ve tak kan ni hlawm a nia.
(nui thu)
Company hma thar lakna awm dawn hi chuan mahni ina hlawkna lo awm ve thei awlsam ber tur chuan enge scrip code? enge symbol? tih zawnga lo ngaihven vat mai tur
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 7:59 pm
@maawma says: ” Mizo ho hi nalh deuh a inchei si hian pachhe ve tak kan ni hlawm a nia.”
Hahaha a dik full.. Hollywood dress nei pha si hi budget a tright hlawm nasa mai si a. Chhungril lam hi alo kawrawng leh huau thin. Christian naah poh heti tho. Kan la thawk ve trek trek hi chuan lawm phot mai ang
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 8:02 pm
Hollywood dress chu tu nge nei a ?
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 8:39 pm
71 haha lolzzzzzzz
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 9:01 pm
Ph atang hian comments first page chhiar theih miah lo, ka ph chu changkang lo c2o3 konia
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 9:56 pm
KFC mmmmm… Ka ril a tam rawih rawih chu leeee
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 11:18 pm
Ka lo hriat ve dan in, KFC leh MacDonald ti tur chuan sum bak ah requirement dang – population, urban area etc te pawh a ngai a ni awm e.
KFC Franchise Mizoram a ti duh tan, information internet ka hmuh thenkhat te.
https://www.indiastudychannel.c.....urant.aspx
https://www.slideshare.net/wade.....esentation
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 11:31 pm
KFC,Macdonald tih vel ai chuan kanu chawhmeh siam leh Masada restaurant a thilsiam tui ka ti zawk..ho emai a.Sap ngaihsan thlak ltk..Kelsa pulao pawh ka duh zawk..
Report this comment
November 28th, 2011 at 11:50 pm
A hlauhom theih dan ber ni a lang (lo ti ve ngot i la)chu kum 30/50 hnuah poisa virvel ram chhungah a tlem a nga chu chuan private a lut vek anga a chhuak leh a tlem toh si anga ram economy in a tuar ang tih a hlauhom…..world economic crisis chhuah tamna chhan ber a an puh ang…….Mahse mipui/grower tan chuan duhthusam a ni thung loi si…………….Man mohan kan nei lom le ti ve ngot………….Lol
Report this comment
November 29th, 2011 at 12:52 am
Aizawla KFC kan hmuh hunah chuan Kawlhawk-a ar hlir kan dawr ang.
KFC siam nana an oil hman hi bawng/vawk thau atanga siam a ni awm e, Hindu/Muslim ho hian ngaih tha deuhin an ei bawk si a an ti
Report this comment
November 29th, 2011 at 1:18 am
Mcdonald’s ai chuan free taka mcdowell’s hmuh ka chak zawk…Hmelchhe ho MI huna KFC (Kawlhawk Fried Chicken) nena an hap ka hmu chak fe zawk…
Report this comment
November 29th, 2011 at 1:21 am
FDI policy hi chu a tha mawle…. mahse distribution and suply chain lam hi venthawn tur awm deuh hlek ang a…
Aizawl khawpuiah pawh hian thlai thartute aiin kharchhawngho hian an hlep tam zawk zel ania….
Report this comment
November 29th, 2011 at 1:26 am
KFC hi Lily-a nen kan ei dun tawh a, mahse ROC (Republic of Chicken) hi ka la try out miah lo ! Fonz-a te veng hnaihah a outlet chu a awm. FM Radio-ah hian an fak ngun nen hian KFC chu a tluk lo deuh a ni mai thei a ni.
Report this comment
November 29th, 2011 at 1:33 am
lushai..weekend try out dawn ami?
Report this comment
November 29th, 2011 at 1:48 am
@Zualbonez : An menu atang hian tribal taste bud a fah lo nghal ringawt a……Desi-ar buh nen chhum han tawp, anthur rep tlem han thlak hi ka chak zawk mah thin…!
KFC hot wings ho hi kerh kerh nen chuan a inrem khawp mai, weekend i lo hman dawn chuan kan ROC anga a ni mai a lawm SouthX lamah outlet an nei a lawm, home delivery pawh an ti thei.
Report this comment
November 29th, 2011 at 3:04 am
50 hmalam kawmen ka kal thei miah lo, ka sawi nawn leh admin ten min chhang lo bawka lol ka kawmen reply lo om poh nise kawmen ve l poh phur awm loh
Report this comment
November 29th, 2011 at 3:05 am
fonz…sify thlak rawh ka tih kha…i offline char char tih a hriat lutuk
Report this comment
November 29th, 2011 at 3:24 am
Tunlai Chu Zualbonez Comment hi ka zo lo..a thlawh fuh thei hawrh hawrh lutuks
Report this comment
November 29th, 2011 at 10:16 am
Nizan LPS chanchintharah khan a puangtu khan a lam fuh theilo tluan zak. A tir berah DRI a tia, a hnuah DFI a ti char char…teleprompter lam ni leh mai thei
Report this comment
November 29th, 2011 at 12:27 pm
lolz Fonzie a chu leh, i va tawng danglam ve… chutiang ang problem chu ka phone atang chuan vawikhatmah ka la tawng lo… eng mobile OS leh mobile browser + version nge i hmana?
Report this comment
November 29th, 2011 at 12:33 pm
78
lushai_er Says: November 29th, 2011 at 12:52
am Aizawla KFC kan hmuh hunah chuan Kawlhawk-a ar hlir kan dawr ang.
Awke… Awke…
Report this comment
November 29th, 2011 at 12:38 pm
79
zualbonez Says: November 29th, 2011 at 1:18
am Mcdonald’s ai chuan free taka mcdowell’s hmuh ka chak zawk…Hmelchhe ho MI huna KFC (Kawlhawk Fried Chicken) nena an hap ka hmu chak fe zawk…
Awke… Awke…
FDI Policy Vs KFC
Report this comment
November 29th, 2011 at 1:51 pm
Maruaris ho hian min awpbet rei toh lutuk a.. I’m all for FDI
Report this comment
November 29th, 2011 at 1:58 pm
#69 @maawma says
KFC leh McDonald’s ah chuan Burger Rs. 400/- chu a awm lo deuh ang a. I risk huai mah mah.. LOL
Report this comment
November 29th, 2011 at 5:01 pm
@Suala, kan ramah kan la zo lo tih sawinan ka rawn hmang uar ve deuh pawh niang e. Mahse naupang ho kha kal ngen fo lo turin ka hrilh ringawt, a man petu kha ka ni thin a, a chhut a in chhut kar kar thin tih takah naupang hoin nitin kal an ngen ziah kha ka khapbet ringawt, rin aiin KFC chu sumthun i nu khawp mai, puar taka ei kha ka inthlahrung tlat a man ka chhut chian let leh hnu hian. Regu taka kal kha hun rei lo te chhungin Credit card bill a ti sang awl dawn tlat. Aman chhut in ka puar ngam lo a ni ber e :-), a aia tlawm puar ve theih tho kha ka hmu tai zawk tlat nih chu mawle LOL
Report this comment
December 19th, 2011 at 7:12 pm
Tlai khaw hnuah ka hmu ve a, ngaihnawm hle mai..Sashi Tharoor thusawi kkhan mi hneh deuh a ni mahna, kei chu FDI hi tha ka ti khawp mai..bakah tha lo se chuan Manmohan Singh hian a rawt awm lo em mai..
Report this comment