To pay or not to pay?

April 12th, 2012 3:59 pm by bbney

(Ka email dawn hi ka rawn copy paste ve leh pawp mai. Enjoy).

A few centuries ago, a Law teacher came across a student who was willing to learn but was unable to pay the fees. The student struck a deal saying, “I will pay your fee the day I win my first case in the court”. Teacher agreed and proceeded with the law course.

When the course was finished and teacher started pestering the student to pay up the fee, the student reminded him of the deal and pushed days. Fed up with this, the teacher decided to sue the student in the court of law and both of them decided to argue for themselves.

The teacher put forward his argument saying:
“If I win this case, as per the court of law, the student has to pay me as the case is about his non-payment of dues. And if I lose the case, student will still pay me because he would have won his first case. So either way I will have to get the money”.

Equally brilliant student argued back saying:
“If I win the case, as per the court of law, I don’t have to pay anything to the teacher as the case is about my non-payment of dues. And if I lose the case, I don’t have to pay him because I haven’t won my first case yet. So either way, I am not going to pay the teacher anything”.

Now who is going to pay?

Similar Posts:

Recent Posts:

36 Responses to “To pay or not to pay?”

  1. 1
    Saitawk Says:

    Chhiar ila..

    Report this comment

  2. 2
    Chhuaklinga Says:

    An thu chu a va buaithlak ve, pakhat a thiam a, pakhat a dik, tih mai chi a nih hi maw le. A inkawlkalh tlat a lawm le. :-O

    tren tren

    Report this comment

  3. 3
    aduhi Says:

    kan hriat miah loh chu: is this the first case the student has won?

    Report this comment

  4. 4
    James Bond Says:

    Ka hre bik lo. Ka hriat chu:
    A dying man called his lawyer and doctor to his bedside. Asked why, he replied, “Jesus was crucified between two thieves just before he died, so do I”

    Report this comment

  5. 5
    bbney Says:

    @u aduhi: ka hre bik miah lo, ka lo zawt leh chhin ang :-P mahse, student hi lo chak zawk pawh ni se, a case hi non-payment of dues kha a nih avangin, a chak hmasak bera fee pe tura an intiamna kha a cancel chiah dawn a, fee pek a ngai tawh dawn lo tihna a ni dawn tho tho a, awmzia a awm chuang lo he2..
    @james bond: good one.

    Report this comment

  6. 6
    Dr Mahminga Sailo Says:

    Pu KL Liana fiamthu ang deuhin, “Lawyer reng reng vanram kai tur pakhat mah an awm lo!” Dawt a sawi ngei a ni tih an hriat rengin an rawih chuan, dawt a sawi lo tia tan char char kha a ngai si a… :-D

    An case kallai mek ah chuan hei hi ka thu tlukna a ni. Tu’n nge pawisa pe ang tih ka hre tlat lo. Pawisa chawitu zawk zawk khian a pe dawn a niang… :-P

    Report this comment

  7. 7
    aduhi Says:

    #5 bbney, assuming this is the first case the student wins, he still has to pay according to the first agreement. A in cancel ringawt thei emi?

    Report this comment

  8. 8
    aduhi Says:

    khawnge funny te, zb te, Asteric, Ignatia te ho hi? Kan lehkhathiam ho

    Report this comment

  9. 9
    bbney Says:

    Chu chu thil awmdan tur nia ka hriat chu ania. Mahse fee a pek loh vanga inkhing an nih avangin pek a ngai dawn lo tihna vel a ang. Ka hre bik lo, mahse student khi a thiam lo zawk ka ti.

    Report this comment

  10. 10
    lrpa Says:

    Now who is going to pay?

    Report this comment

  11. 11
    Sãñgpüîípã Says:

    Ka thluak a buai map mai.

    Report this comment

  12. 12
    Asteric™ Says:

    #8@aduhi…lehkhathiam ka la ni lo aniang ka chalrem thei lo tlat ;-)
    An agreement khi a fuh/kim zan lo a nih hmel. Student in court a First case a solve tur ah khian an agreement neih khi case hmasa bera chhiar tel nghal theih a nih chuan a tir aṭanga an deal ah khian teacher tan awmzia a awm lo nghal sa hrim hrim in ka hria.

    Report this comment

  13. 13
    Dr Mahminga Sailo Says:

    An thubuai hi a buaithlak em mai.., Lawyer rawih tur an awm chuan, UKIl ruai mai rawh se… :-P

    Report this comment

  14. 14
    Alejendro Says:

    Uiii Pi Aduhi chu min lam tel ve miahlo.. ka rilru a van na.. :-P

    Report this comment

  15. 15
    Asteric™ Says:

    ‘Engatinge student first case ah ber kher teacher in an agreement a put luh, case dang a buaipui hun nghak ve mai sela’ te k tia :D

    Report this comment

  16. 16
    aduhi Says:

    Alejendro nang te chu supergenius level i nia lawm.

    Report this comment

  17. 17
    Sandman Says:

    OBJECTION, YOUR HONOUR!!!

    Report this comment

  18. 18
    aduhi Says:

    eng movie nge ni kha aw mi pakhat mawl ve deuh hian Your Honour tih aiah Your Majesty a tih sek kha, Your Highness emawni zawk ni

    Report this comment

  19. 19
    lrpa Says:

    he case hi a ho! awmze awm lo anih hi! zirtirtu khian student kha courtah a khing a. Hei hi student tan a first case ani lo khrim khrim phawt. (Jury system ah chuan erawh defendant kha ukil ah a tang nghal thei tho em kha aw!).
    Student hi lo thiam ta zawk pawh nise, thiam zawk ani mai a, engmah hlawh tur a nei chuang lo.
    Heng te avang hian case in rawn chhawp hi ka admit thei lo ani e. :-)

    Report this comment

  20. 20
    Jennifer Lo Says:

    An pa 2 hian man a lungin tantir a pawisa chawitir bawk tur!! ;-)
    Law teacher tur a qualified lo puiin law a lo zirtir ve ngawt a vangin impersonation/impostor case
    Student pawh hi recognised institution pawh ni hleilo a trang a law lo zir ve ngawt leh ukil lo INTI ve ringawt hi court leh ukil tak tak te zah lohnaah ka ngai
    Bar council pawh hi lo in enchiang se hetiang mi licence anlo pe mai hi an integrity a chianglo emni?? :-P

    Report this comment

  21. 21
    Master Kim Says:

    Hei in case hi ka han en vang vanga zirlai pawh hi puitling a nih ve tho hmela chuvangin patling leh patling chu Retailer patla lianah inbuk mai se a kang zawk zawkin a kang lo zawk thu zawm mai se. Ka ti deuh. Hehehee.hiiiiiii.

    Report this comment

  22. 22
    bbney Says:

    #21 Master Kim :-D
    #20: (H)

    Report this comment

  23. 23
    ultimate Says:

    Master Kim, retailer patla a? In veng retailer-in patla a nei bik elo? Kan khua velah chuan kg 10 chinah tin bungin an suak a, a aia tlemah chuan bowl-in an suak. DCSO chuan buk tur chu a tia, an zawm lem hlei law. an man chuang hlei law! Saitawk te lah hi indaih thei hek lo, sa buk erawh an chek ngun deuh.

    Report this comment

  24. 24
    RenghangMan Says:

    A ngaihna ka hre bik miahlo mai!

    Report this comment

  25. 25
    Flames Says:

    A course fee nge tam a case fee le? :-)

    Report this comment

  26. 26
    malsta27 Says:

    comment en chuan in khirh khiap hmel hlom mai2 :-D ;-)

    Report this comment

  27. 27
    loneeagle26016 Says:

    Hmmm…Court case anih chuan a case neitute statement anga judgement an siam mai ten a dik tawp nang mawle…payment chungchang anih avngin teacher khian a lose vaih chuan pawisa a dawng dawn lo, chutiangbawkin student khian a lose vaih chuan pawisa pek a ngai ang. A chhan chu judgement khan a rule miau dawn avng ani mai…hairehai :-D

    Report this comment

  28. 28
    bbney Says:

    #27: dik ve leh reng. Judge a thu ber :-D

    Report this comment

  29. 29
    ChhanaPa Says:

    Student khian a pek ngei2 theih nan ka theihtawp ka lo chhuah ang.. MLTP Act Section 81 ah chuan………..

    Report this comment

  30. 30
    PKfanai Says:

    An in draw. Chuan zirlai a hlawk zawk. ;-)

    Report this comment

  31. 31
    johnny_ralte Says:

    Lolz Teacher a chak chuan Rs. 10000 (assuming) a hlawh ang. A chak loh chuan Rs. 10000 tho a hlawh ang. Student a chak chuan engmah pek ngailo ang. Mahse a chakloh chuan Rs. 10000 a pek angai ang. A case chak hmasak berah Rs. 10000 a pe leh ang. SOLVED

    Report this comment

  32. 32
    Master Kim Says:

    #31. Ni e. (Y)

    Report this comment

  33. 33
    bbney Says:

    A chak zawkin cheng nuaih leh sial ti mai ang

    Report this comment

  34. 34
    littlerascal Says:

    What if the Teacher do not represents himself? :)

    Report this comment

  35. 35
    Jacka Pi Says:

    :-S

    Report this comment

  36. 36
    Maisek Says:

    The Student is going to pay….definitely… :-)

    Report this comment

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.